ANNA MARIA – Restaurateur Sean Murphy has withdrawn his bid proposal to lease the city-owned restaurant and bait shop buildings at the end of the new Anna Maria City Pier.
Today, Sean Murphy sent Anna Maria Mayor Dan Murphy a note regarding his decision to withdraw his offer. The mayor then forwarded copies of that digital communication to city commissioners, along with his own response.
In his note to the mayor, Sean Murphy wrote, “It was my intention when I entered the RFP process to be as helpful as possible to you in your endeavor to find the best operator for your pier franchise. I was far from certain that the operator should be me, but I was convinced that I could be helpful.
“Since I formed that resolution our community has been assaulted by a pandemic. The hospitality industry has been turned on its head. I was dismayed when my RFP became one of only two submitted at the closing date and was further dismayed when the motion was made and then passed that we would be the first negotiant. I believe we have fallen into a difficult time for planning any hospitality project. It is not your fault that in the middle of your RFP mechanism our world has turned inside out,” Sean Murphy wrote.
“I would recommend to you and the commission that you begin the RFP process over again when potential applicants have adjusted to the new environment and can make better decisions. I am certain that you will receive more and better proposals than you have now. I am withdrawing my proposal and encouraging you and the commission to begin again,” Sean Murphy wrote.
In response, Mayor Dan Murphy wrote, “Sean. Thank you for your note. I will relay your note to our commissioners. Our city appreciates your having taken the time to bid and hope that if a new RFP is issued, you would consider submitting an offer again. This will confirm receipt of your notification withdrawing your offer from further consideration for the City Pier restaurant.”
Previous actions
During the special city commission meeting on Wednesday, the commission voted 4-1 in favor of authorizing Mayor Murphy to begin pier lease negotiations with Sean Murphy, the owner-operator of the Beach Bistro and Eat Here restaurants in Holmes Beach, where he also owns and operates The Doctor’s Office craft cocktail bar.
Commissioners Joe Muscatello, Mark Short and Amy Tripp supported Commissioner Jon Crane’s motion to move forward with Sean Murphy as the commission’s preferred pier tenant. Commissioner Carol Carter opposed that decision.
The commission majority selected Sean Murphy’s offer to pay the city $14,000 per month in base rent over the $18,000 in monthly base rent offered by the Ugly Grouper LCC group that includes Ugly Grouper restaurant co-owner Mike Ross and General Manager Thad Treadwell.
On Friday, Tripp submitted a request to rescind the commission’s pier lease decision. Tripp’s request for a “Motion to rescind action taken at meeting of May 6,” was then placed on the agenda for the commission’s next meeting on Thursday, May 14.
On Sunday, Sean Murphy withdrew his offer. Now that he has withdrawn his offer, the commission will decide on Thursday whether to authorize Dan Murphy to begin lease negotiations with Ross and the Ugly Grouper LLC or to reject both bids received and issue another request for proposals (RFP) as part of its efforts to secure a new pier tenant.
Thursday’s meeting
Because city hall remains closed to the public due the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, Thursday’s commission meeting will again be conducted via telephone, and public comment will be allowed. The meeting will start at 2 p.m. To listen to and/or participate in Thursday’s meeting call 1-408-650-3123 before the meeting starts. When prompted, enter the access code, which is 590303789.
